Just an update from TechCrunch on a story that generated a lot of controversy a few months back, “Did Last.fm Just Hand Over User Listening Data To the RIAA?”
Now we’ve located another source for the story, someone who’s very close to Last.fm. And it turns out Last.fm was telling the truth, sorta… Last.fm didn’t hand user data over to the RIAA. According to our source, it was their parent company, CBS, that did it. Here’s what we believe happened: CBS requested user data from Last.fm, including user name and IP address. CBS wanted the data to comply with a RIAA request but told Last.fm the data was going to be used for ‘internal use only.’ It was only after the data was sent to CBS that Last.fm discovered the real reason for the request. Last.fm staffers were outraged, say our sources, but the data had already been sent to the RIAA. We believe CBS lied to us when they denied sending the data to the RIAA, and that they subsequently asked us to attribute the quote to Last.fm to make the statement defensible. Last.fm’s denials were strictly speaking correct, but they ignored the underlying truth of the situation, that their parent company supplied user data to the RIAA, and that the data could possibly be used in civil and criminal actions against those users.
The reply by Last-fm is full of lawyer talk. They don’t actually just say “it didn’t happen.”
Nobody at Last.fm knows anything about such a leak.
Translation: Leaked by CBS, without Last.fm’s knowledge.
Any suggestion that we were complicit in transferring user data to any third party is incorrect.
Translation: CBS did it on their behalf, therefore Last.Fm weren’t complicit.
The suggestion that CBS’s ops team provided this data is just not possible.
Translation: Some other dept. eg legal provided the data.
Maybe I’m just cynical, but I used to work for a company that employed lawyers to lie to tax officials on a regular basis. This isn’t a blanket denial – it’s full of holes and out clauses. Just what a lawyer would write.
Related Posts: On this day...
- Announcing the release of Fedora 15 (Lovelock) - 2011
- Next Linux kernel release could be 2.8.0 - 2011
- I wish this guy the best - 2010
- Typhoid adware hijacks LAN, inserts ads into uninfected computers' browsers - 2010
- Coach Mike Brown pays the price for Cavs' early playoff exit - 2010
- Zappos lost $1.6 million over-night due to pricing mistake... and honors prices - 2010
- 3D Projection on Buildings - 2010
- Lifelock CEO Todd Davis becomes ID theft victim - 2008